Wednesday, April 10, 2019

Hypersonic Research works Published in High Impact Factor Journal is Erroneous


This post should concern the Hypersonic researchers. It is about reporting a ridiculous research work published in a reputed journal which also declined to publish my “Comments” that reports the errors/mistakes of the published article. Firstly, I informed about the errors/mistakes of the published article to a retired Professor who is ex-Head of that Laboratory, then informed the first author of the article and finally reported to The Editor of the journal. Since all went in vain and my intention is to let other researchers know about the errors in the published article so that they can use the data with utmost caution and spare their time, I decided to publish it in an archive (http://viXra.org/abs/1903.0557) and provide its background here.
Paper title: Comments on “Aerothermodynamic Effects of Controlled Heat Release Within the Hypersonic Shock Layer Around a Large Angle Blunt Cone” [phys. Fluids 30, 106103 (2018)]
Paper title: Comments on “Aerodynamic Drag Reduction by Heat Addition Into the Shock Layer for a Large Angle Blunt Cone in Hypersonic Flow” [physics of Fluids 20, 081703 (2008)]
Please forward this to the concerned researchers which would save their precious time and effort. PS: I spend more than two years of my PhD convincing my Professor that the data given to me by my senior is wrong. This is one of the primary reason why I am very much concerned about this.
An article titled “Aerothermodynamic effects of controlled heat release within the hypersonic shock layer around a large angle blunt cone” was published in a Physics of Fluids journal in October 2018 (https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5046191). The Physics of Fluids journal is one of the highly reputed journal in the world of Fluid dynamics with an impact factor of ~2.3. This article was a featured article of that month.
This article is about investigating a flow physics of a spacecraft if its surface is coated with chromium using four different measurement techniques (heat flux using thin film sensors, temperature using pyrometry technique, shock stand-off distance using flow visualization technique) and also matched the experimental results with computational simulation (CFD) results. I found all the four measurement techniques were improperly used and the data was manipulated to achieve the desired results. On top of these, the test conditions itself were wrongly calculated which is used as an input to perform computational simulation. I discussed it with few experts. We found the scientific errors are substantial and so stupid. The errors are very obvious to any Experimental Hypersonic/Supersonic expert. One of the expert described it as “The article contains substantial claims with mere evidences from a vague research methodology with questionable outcomes”.
I contacted the first author of the paper and his answers were not convincing. So I decided to list out the major errors and send it to the Physics of Fluids journal to be published as “Comments”. The Editor immediately rejected it saying the first paragraph was mean-spirited. I immediately send an apologising letter and requested for resubmission. I rephrased the words and resubmitted my “Comments”. It was rejected again after the peer-review process. The first reviewer have strongly recommended my “Comments” for publication. Please find the detailed reviewers comments towards the end of the post. The second reviewer seems to have mistaken the manuscript type as “Full length paper” instead of “Comments” and refused it to publish it as a standalone paper as there is no new science involved. The second reviewer’s comments goes as follows:
“This article seeks to question the data presented in an earlier paper and, in itself, adds nothing new to the science involved. It seems to me that the objections should be taken up directly with the authors of the original paper, rather than being published as a standalone paper. If the author wishes to publish on this matter then I would recommend that they complete a set of experiments of their own, at similar conditions, and highlight any differences.”
As a policy of Physics of Fluids, "Comments are to address scientific issues in a very concise and substantive manner with no harsh criticism" (https://aip.scitation.org/phf/info/policies). It is basically to notify the errors in the article to other researchers so that the other researchers can use the data with utmost caution. In this case no new science material or additional experimental data are required as suggested by the second reviewer. Many such comments have been published in the past. So I immediately wrote an email to the Associate Editor clarifying that my manuscript type is "Comment/Response" and not "Full length paper" for which I received a reply from The Editor that they are not at liberty to publish material that has not satisfied the reviewers.
I didn’t expect such vague statements as a reason for rejection from a highly reputed journal. I believe that people in academic research can get a feel of this situation. Whatever!!! Open access journal and social networking sites gives life to such issues.  
In fact the same research group have published an article in 2008 in Physics of Fluids titled “Aerodynamic drag reduction by heat addition into the shock layer for a large angle blunt cone in hypersonic flow“ (https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2944982). Another research group performed numerical simulations on this work and found a large discrepancy (>50%) with the experimental results. The results are published in (https://doi.org/10.1177/0954410013490849) International Journal of Heat and Mass transfer in 2014. I found the reason for such a discrepancy is due to improper data analysis of the experimental signals and I notice similar kind of lethargic research work with the present one as well. The same is also reported in an open access journal (http://viXra.org/abs/1903.0555).
Please find the details of my “Comments” for both the papers in the following links:
Paper title: Comments on “Aerothermodynamic Effects of Controlled Heat Release Within the Hypersonic Shock Layer Around a Large Angle Blunt Cone” [phys. Fluids 30, 106103 (2018)]
Paper title: Comments on “Aerodynamic Drag Reduction by Heat Addition Into the Shock Layer for a Large Angle Blunt Cone in Hypersonic Flow” [physics of Fluids 20, 081703 (2008)]
Please cascade the information to the concerned researchers which would save their precious time and effort.
Referee Comments:
Referee #1 (Comments to Both Author and Editor):
I have read the comments and the associated article by Deep and Jagadeesh. I agree with the present author that the purported effects on the flow field due to the chromium coating are based on very tenuous experimental data and a weak theoretical analysis (Ref. 14 from the original article). I encourage the publication of the comment by Anbuselvan because it raises fair questions about the validity of the prior work. I cannot comment on all of the specific issues that Anbuselvan raises, but they appear to be valid concerns and should be brought to light.
Regarding the previous paper, I have the following issues:
1. the test time is extremely short and during the so-called steady test time, there are very large variations in pitot pressure and heat flux. These variations are of the same scale as the differences supposedly measured.
2. The authors say that they ran at least 5 cases, but there is nothing presented to show the resulting variation. Why not?
3. The estimates of the free-stream conditions have unrealistically small error bars, as do all other reported experimental data. How can the heat flux be measured to 2.3% accuracy, when there are order 30% variations in heat flux during the test time. This is ludicrous at best.
4. Why not just do some runs with N2 as the test gas on the chromium coated model; that would at least provide some verification that an inert gas would not produce the same effect -- though given the variations discussed above, I am not sure these effects can be discriminated.
5. Reference [14] is qualitatively valid at best. It provides no support to the experimental data shown in the subject paper.
Referee #2 (Comments to Both Author and Editor):
This article seeks to question the data presented in an earlier paper and, in itself, adds nothing new to the science involved. It seems to me that the objections should be taken up directly with the authors of the original paper, rather than being published as a standalone paper. If the author wishes to publish on this matter then I would recommend that they complete a set of experiments of their own, at similar conditions, and highlight any differences.


Saturday, November 20, 2010

My First Audition

Chocolate to our Lovely Senior

Back ground

Teja Conscious: I am Teja. I and Nikhil are close friends studying 3rd year Mechanical Engineering. We are happy that in few weeks time we will became “the seniors” of our college but at the same time we are sad that we will be missing the angels of our senior’s batch.

Scene 1: Class room during morning tea break

Nikhil is sitting on a chair of joint-school-desk-and-chair and Teja is sitting on the desk of the same joint-school-desk-and-chair, both facing towards the audience.

Nikhil: (Sadly looking at the floor) Dude, today is the last day. She will leave the campus.

Teja: (Turning towards Nikhil in a confused state) Whom are you speaking about?

Nikhil: (Looking at Teja) Swetha.

(Shot is frozen) Teja Conscious: Swetha is our senior who is about to complete her degree in IT. Many of my mates look at her, including me. My friend likes her a lot but he never tried to speak to her. Not only to her but to any of the girls because he is scared that he would be embarrassed by them.

Teja: oh, that pretty roomly figure (Nikhil scowls at Teja), oops sorry, it’s just a slip of the tongue; that pretty homely figure.

Nikhil: (in a loud voice) If your tongue slips, apply fevicol and stick it. (After a pause & in a soft voice) Should do something. (Hastily) Atleast should give a chocolate to her.

Teja: Then give!

Nikhil: Hey dude help me man. You already have experience on it by giving a PERK chocolate to your girlfriend; that too during our first year itself.

Teja: Man, she is not my girlfriend. I just tried to speak with her and it is because of you guys, I started hitting on her and became mad about her. And last week she told that she has a boyfriend already.

Nikhil: Hey, are these things new to you or what. But still you have guts, buddy.

Teja: (Jumps from the desk and stands on the floor) Alright. (Facing Nikhil) I will help you. Buy one PERK chocolate now and keep it with you. I will look after the rest.

Scene 2: Canteen during lunch

Both Nikhil & Teja are sitting in the canteen facing each other, and Nikhil is looking at the canteen’s entrance for her arrival.

Teja: Has she come?

Nikhil: No da. Hey dude, many people are in canteen. What shall we do if it becomes an embarrassing moment?

Teja: If you are concerned about that, then we can’t speak to any girl. C’mon man you should lose your dignity and respect after you joined mechanical. Oh shit!, there goes the bell, let’s get back to the class; let’s try in the evening; let’s see how your luck works?

Scene 3: Around 6 PM; Nikhil just entered the canteen and Teja was following him

Nikhil: (excitedly) Dude there she is and no one is in the canteen except she and her friends.

Teja: (Softly) Ok ok. Control your excitement. That’s true but some of her friends are guys, so let’s sit near the counter and wait for the opportunity.

She gets up from her chair and comes to the counter. She buys cool drinks and is returning to her chair.

Teja: This is the time. Get up fast buddy. Hello Akka ........

She turns back.

Teja: I am Teja. He is my friend Nikhil. We know you. Today is your last day right? So thought of giving you a chocolate, just consider it as our compliment.

Swetha: (Smilingly) Oh thank u. Which department are you guys from?

Teja: Mechanical

She shows an awkward face.

Teja: Which company you got placed?

Swetha: Infosys

Nikhil: Your posting, akka?

Swetha: Pune

Teja: ok akka, best wishes. We will catch up sometime. (Nikhil frowns at Teja for ending the conversation so soon)

She shakes hands. Then Nikhil & Teja exits the canteen.

Nikhil: (Hugs Teja in overjoy) Hey dude thanks man, you rocked. You made her to shake hands with me!!!! I will not wash my hands for a week atleast.

Teja: Even I didn’t expect that. Ok Ok when is the treat?

Nikhil: Soon buddy.

Scene 4: The next day during lunch in the canteen

Teja is working in the lab and his phone rings.

Teja: hey tell me buddy.

Nikhil: Hey where are you. Come fast. Swetha is in canteen

Teja: Ok I am coming now.

Scene 5: Teja just entered into the canteen

Teja sees Nikhil standing far away from Swetha. Teja approaches Swetha who is sitting along-with her friends.

Swetha: (On seeing Teja) Oh oh. Now what? (Teja: akka.... )- next you guys keep coming and will start to take advantage. (She takes the chocolate from her bag) Take the chocolate and leave me.

Teja: (Hastily) Oops. akka, you keep the chocolate yourselves (Then Teja walked hastily towards Nikhil).

Nikhil sees the Teja conversation with Swetha and starts approaching them. Teja signals him not to come. But he didn’t listen and signs that he also wants to join in the conversation. So Teja drags him to the other corner of the canteen where few of their friends having lunch.

Nikhil: (With anger) Stupid, why are you so selfish?

Teja: (With anger) You asshole, you want to be embarrassed.

Nikhil: (in a slow voice) What happened?

Teja: She said we are annoying her. But that didn’t bother me much. She.... she...... she is still having that chocolate in her bag. (After a pause) May be I should have got that chocolate from her.

PS: I would like to express my gratitude to my friend’s sister who grammatically corrected the script.

Mosuo: a community with unique & astonishing tradition















We have different religion, caste, sub-caste, language, ethnicity in this world - from east to west, north to south, rich to tribes. Each genre have their own customs and traditions, but what remains common to all genres is the basic family structure i.e., Father, mother and their children. Besides that, we can find gay couples & their children, and lesbian couples & their children, rarely. Had you witnessed or heard any other family structure? At least I had not!

But recently I heard a completely different family structure; a family structure without a father or husband - sounding strange right? and they are called Mosuo. Mosuo, a small minority ethnic group living around Lake Lugu which share the borders of Yunnan and Sichuan provinces of China. They live in a mountainous region whose primary occupation is agriculture and farming as like any other village people in this world. But their traditions of Matriarchal family system and most importantly - the Walking marriage make them distinct from any other existing known community in this world.

Mosuo women are given high preference with due respect and Mosuo follows a matriarchal family system in contrast to our male-dominated family system. In such a kind of system, the family tree consists of only maternal branch since Mosuo don’t prefer to have a father for their child. In many cases, their children are unaware of their father and hence there is no place for paternal branch at all in the family tree. Women will have physical relationship only with the men whom they like and they are free to do it at any number of times with any number of people since the age of 13, and this is referred as "Walking marriage". Mothers teach about sex to their daughters after their age ceremony and they say "Sex is good for skin". It is either the mother or mother's brother responsibility to raise the child.

Mosuo community became so popular to outside world after a well-known Chinese pop singer Namu who left Lugu at her young age, recently released a book “Leaving her mother” after which the government improved the infrastructure to make it as a hot tourist destination spot, thereby reducing a week trekking to hours travel to reach Lugu from outside world. Many tourists visit Lugu looking for free sex because of which Mosuo females are really disturbed. Taking the advantage of this tradition and tourists disappointment of free sex, some prostitutes travel from town and clad themselves as Mosuo and provide them the sex. Thus the access to Lugu by outside world presages the rise of deterioration of Mosuo community. At present, Namu works for the welfare of the uplift of their community, and tries to protect the community & their traditions by building a museum and through various charities.

I came to know about Mosuo community through a documentary "The Great Himalayas". Follow the link to know more about Mosuo community:

http://factsanddetails.com/china.php?itemid=182&catid=5&subcatid=87

Wikipedia - Mosuo

Endhiran


Endhiran - a whooping sum of Rs. 120 crore worth contents were finally presented on a big screen. A perfect commercial sci-fi entertainer and I feel it deserves all credits. Thanks to SRK who officially announced to drop the project after which it slipped into Rajni's hands (Infact Rajni was the first person to hear this script couple of years before but refused it for some reasons).

Shankar dominates the first half of movie and Rajni performance excels in the second half. The movie is completely out of Rajni's formula - no formal introduction song, no punch dialogues, no mannerisms, no sentiments to please oldies, and no yesteryear actors like Gandhimathi :). Rajni's performance as a villain is really awesome, particularly his dialogue delivery is so perfect which reminds me his old movies like Netrikan and 16 Vayathinile. Though the creativity for graphics looks childish and inspired from various Hollywood movies, they are presented with utmost care and perfection than any other Tamil movies before. Dialogues are well-written; short, crisp and meaningful. The one thing which I really miss in the movie is Rajni's stylish stunt. Last but not the least, it is claimed that the movie is an adaptation of a Tamil novel (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endhiran) which is still a controversy, and I DOT this review with the below tagline :).

Tagline: Endhiran – An attempt to make a movie using the modern technology - is successful.

PS: I decided to watch Endhiran, a month after its release, since the ticket rates were very high. But I could not refrain from watching the movie due to the headlines that it made on newspapers day-by-day. Finally I and my lab-mates decided and booked the tickets for a Monday night show in Inox Bangalore. Not even a single whistle was blown by anyone in the theatre hall throughout the movie though I watched it on the fourth day of movie release because I watched the movie along-with the so called elite community :(. Finally I managed to blow one whistle for Superstar title. Whereas the nearby local Natraj theatre have erected a megasized cut-out for Superstar which is garlanded with different flowers. Anyway - my Coimbatore theatre doors are calling me for the second time :) to witness the Superstar’s fan maniac actions.

Masters of Sex

I have heard many crazy stories about scientific research and discoveries from fellow researchers during my PhD days in IISc and I am so ...